Hyperoxic Brain Effects Are Normalized by Addition of CO2
Paul M. Macey1, Mary A. Woo2, Ronald M. Harper1*
1 Department of Neurobiology, David Geffen School of Medicine, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, United States of America, 2 School of Nursing, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, United States of America
Funding: This work was supported by the National Institutes of Health Child Health and Human Development grant HD-22695. The study sponsor had no role in study design; collection, analysis, and interpretation of data; writing of the paper; or decision to submit for publication.
Competing Interests: The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Academic Editor: Mervyn Singer, University College London, United Kingdom
Citation: Macey PM, Woo MA, Harper RM (2007) Hyperoxic brain effects are normalized by addition of CO2. PLoS Med 4(5): e173. doi:10.
Received: June 26, 2006
Accepted: March 19, 2007
Published: May 22, 2007
Copyright: © 2007 Macey et al. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Abbreviations: BOLD, blood- oxygen level dependent; CBF, cerebral blood flow; fMRI, functional magnetic resonance imaging
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: [email protected] edu
A B S T R A C T
Hyperoxic ventilation (.21% O2) is widely used in medical practice for resuscitation, stroke intervention, and chronic supplementation. However, despite the objective of improving tissue oxygen delivery, hyperoxic ventilation can accentuate ischemia and impair that outcome. Hyperoxia results in, paradoxically, increased ventilation, which leads to hypocapnia, diminishing cerebral blood flow and hindering oxygen delivery. Hyperoxic delivery induces other systemic changes, including increased plasma insulin and glucagon levels and reduced myocardial contractility and relaxation, which may derive partially from neurally mediated hormonal and sympathetic outflow. Several cortical, limbic, and cerebellar brain areas regulate these autonomic processes. The aim of this study was to assess recruitment of these regions in response to hyperoxia and to determine whether any response would be countered by addition of CO2 to the hyperoxic gas mixture.
Methods and Findings
We studied 14 children (mean age 11 y, range 8–15 y). We found, using functional magnetic resonance imaging, that 2 min of hyperoxic ventilation (100% O2) following a room air baseline elicited pronounced responses in autonomic and hormonal control areas, including the hypothalamus, insula, and hippocampus, throughout the challenge. The addition of 5% CO2 to 95% O2 abolished responses in the hypothalamus and lingual gyrus, substantially reduced insular, hippocampal, thalamic, and cerebellar patterns in the first 48 s, and abolished signals in those sites thereafter. Only the dorsal midbrain responded to hypercapnia, but not hyperoxia.
In this group of children, hyperoxic ventilation led to responses in brain areas that modify hypothalamus-mediated sympathetic and hormonal outflow; these responses were diminished by addition of CO2 to the gas mixture. This study in healthy children suggests that supplementing hyperoxic administration with CO2 may mitigate central and peripheral consequences of hyperoxia.
The Editors’ Summary of this article follows the references.
Hyperoxic ventilation (.21% O2) is widely used in medical practice, both in acute applications, such as resuscitation and stroke, and for chronic ventilatory supplementation. How- ever, despite the objective of improving tissue oxygen delivery, hyperoxia can accentuate ischemia and impair that outcome. After initially suppressing ventilation through peripheral chemoreceptor action, hyperoxic gas mixtures paradoxically increase ventilation , likely by exciting chemosensitive brainstem neurons, possibly by an O2 free radical mechanism . Reduced CO2–hemoglobin binding from increased O2 (the Haldane effect ) may additionally contribute to enhanced ventilation. The increase in ventila- tion due to hyperoxic exposure occurs also in neonates  and is long-lasting . The hyperoxia-induced ventilatory increases result in reduced PCO2 and diminished cerebral blood ﬂow (CBF) . Oxygen delivery is further hindered by increasing the afﬁnity of hemoglobin for O2 and reducing O2 unloading to tissues .
Hyperoxic challenges elicit local effects on brainstem sites, but also modify neural regulatory areas that mediate autonomic outﬂow and hormonal release. Signiﬁcant in- creases in plasma glucagon and insulin levels and reduced myocardial contractility and relaxation result from even short hyperoxia exposures , and modiﬁcations in heart rate and blood pressure with hyperoxia are common [8,9]. Such hormonal and cardiovascular effects require involvement of central autonomic and hormonal regulation areas.
The particular brain structures recruited to inﬂuence hypothalamic and other autonomic and hormonal outﬂow responses to hyperoxia have been outlined by a large body of neuroanatomic and electrophysiologic data in animal models and functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) studies of cold pressor or ventilatory challenges in humans [10–15]. Hypothalamic contributions to hormonal and sympathetic nervous system outﬂow are not regulated in isolation, but depend on multiple limbic and cortical regions, including insular, cingulate cortex, and hippocampal projections to particular hypothalamic sites [16,17]. The resulting hypo- thalamic inﬂuences on sympathetic ventral medullary ﬁnal common path regions are modulated by such structures as the cerebellar cortex and deep nuclei, which limit or dampen extreme sympathetic changes (e.g., those occurring during profound decreases in blood pressure), and the insular cortex, which exerts lateralized inﬂuences on baroreceptor reﬂexes and other autonomic patterns . Several limbic and cortical sites, including the insula and cingulate cortex, contribute to modulating the hypothalamo-pituitary-adreno- cortical response to stress .
CBF reduction due to hyperoxia can be mitigated by
adding CO2 to the gas mixture . Elevations in CO2 lead to vasodilation of cerebral arteries and increased blood ﬂow , and the addition of CO2 can alleviate a principal consequence of hyperoxic exposure—hypocapnia . It is unclear, however, whether addition of CO2 modiﬁes re- sponses of brain areas that regulate sympathetic and hormonal outﬂow, potentially altering the central response of hyperoxia on peripheral vascular and organ responses, or whether the CO2 effects are conﬁned to cerebral vasodilation, with little consequence to essential neural responses to hyperoxia. We hypothesized that hyperoxic exposure would
elicit elevated responses in brain areas that regulate hypothalamic action, and that the magnitude of fMRI signals in brain areas mediating sympathetic and hormonal control should be diminished with the addition of CO2. Although it would be desirable to evaluate these issues in neonates, who are most likely to be exposed to resuscitation with hyperoxia, logistic issues with movement control in an environment not appropriate for sedation precluded use of such participants. We thus used an older group of children to investigate our hypotheses.
Participants and Informed Consent
Participants were 14 healthy children (age in years: mean 11, standard devation 2, range 8–15; seven male, seven female) participated. No participant had any diagnosis or evidence of respiratory or other disorders. Participants and parents or guardians provided written consent, and the procedures were approved by the Institutional Review Board of the University of California at Los Angeles, and comply with the Declaration of Helsinki.
Data were acquired with a General Electric 1.5 T Magnetic Resonance Imaging unit. Participants lay supine and breathed through a mouthpiece connected to a two-way non-rebreather valve. End-tidal CO2 and ECG signals were measured and transmitted to a recording system outside the scanner room. These signals were subsequently used to calculate heart and respiratory rates. For monitoring pur- poses, pulse oxygen saturation was also measured. The fMRI data consisted of gradient-echo echo-planar images (repeti- tion time [TR] 6,000 ms per volume, time to echo [TE] 60 ms, ﬂip angle 908, ﬁeld of view [FOV] 30 3 30 cm, no
interslice gap, voxel size 2.3 32.3 35.0 mm) composed of 20 oblique sections, and the protocol was a 144 s series of 24 volumes with gas challenges administered 24 s into the series and lasting for the remaining 120 s. Series were collected during each of three conditions: baseline (no gas adminis- tered), hyperoxia (100% O2), and hypercapnic hyperoxia (5% CO2, balance O2). Gas mixtures were delivered via the inspiratory arm of the valve. A minimum of 8 min elapsed between challenges, allowing the participants to return to a baseline state, as veriﬁed by physiologic signals.
Data were analyzed using the Statistical Parametric Map- ping software SPM (http://www.ﬁl.ion.ucl.ac.uk/spm). Each fMRI series was corrected for timing differences in slice acquisition, and motion-corrected; series with more than 4 mm of translation or more than 18 of rotation in any direction were excluded from the analysis. Images were then spatially normalized (full details are described elsewhere ) and segmented into gray matter, white matter, and CSF. The segmentation relies upon signal intensity differences between gray and white matter regions in the fMRI images, and atlas- based probability distribution maps of the tissue types . The technique is robust to distortions in the images; partial volume effects arise due to the low resolution of the fMRI images, but a probability threshold of 0.5 for classiﬁcation of gray matter ensured that the majority of gray matter regions
were included in gray matter images. The fMRI images are sensitive to changes in blood-oxygen levels; the signal is derived from the relative proportion of deoxygenated and oxygenated blood (termed blood-oxygen level dependent [BOLD] signal). Hyperoxia and hypercapnia cause global changes in the BOLD signal from CBF and oxygenation alterations, which confound the effect of interest (local changes in blood oxygenation—and hence in the BOLD signal—corresponding indirectly to changes in local ﬁeld potentials and hence neuronal activation). The magnitude and timing of the global signal changes differ between white and gray matter [23,24]; thus, only the latter images were analyzed. Within each individual’s gray matter fMRI time series, all global effects were removed using a conservative detrending method . The detrended images were smoothed (full-width-half-maximum 8 mm).
The two gas challenges were analyzed separately. A linear model was constructed with ﬁve step-function independent variables for each child, set to 1 (‘‘on’’) during each of ﬁve 24-s periods of the challenge and 0 (‘‘off’’) otherwise. The model was convolved with the SPM standard hemodynamic response function. The baseline series was included during the ‘‘off’’ period. Each series also included a constant term to account for variations in absolute signal intensity. The signal intensity at each voxel (i.e., each ‘‘pixel’’ or sample point in the image volume) across individuals was modeled as a linear function of the step-function variables and constants, and tested for positive or negative effects (F-test), corresponding to increas- ing or decreasing signal intensity during the challenge (termed a ﬁxed-effects analysis). The F-test ﬁndings indicated absolute responses, regardless of the direction of signal changes.
All analyses were performed across the group of 14 participants. Each voxel was evaluated using a signiﬁcance threshold of p , 0.05, with false discovery rate correction for multiple comparisons . The results from all voxels were combined into a whole-brain statistical ‘‘map’’ of areas showing signiﬁcant signal changes. As each time-period was evaluated independently, a map was generated for each 24 s period of a gas challenge. Statistical effect sizes were calculated using Pearson’s r calculated from the formula
devise a method to remove such effects . Physiologic data were analyzed previously as part of an investigation into CCHS and have been reported separately .
The physiologic patterns of response to the challenges, reported earlier in a subset of 12 of the current 14 children , were similar to those reported elsewhere. The expected decline in heart rate due to hyperoxia  appeared after one minute. Respiratory rate showed a brief increase; tidal volume, which was not measured, is responsible for the majority of the reported increased ventilation due to hyper- oxia, with respiratory rate not greatly affected [32,33]. Hypercapnia induced a sustained rise in both respiratory and cardiac rates, as anticipated . Trends in end-tidal CO2, an increase due to hypercapnia and decrease to hyperoxia, were also consistent with the established physio- logic literature.
Hyperoxia elicited a sequence of fMRI responses in the posterior hypothalamus, insula, hippocampus, cerebellum, caudate, and thalamic regions (Figure 1). The areas high- lighted in Figure 1 exhibited signal patterns that increased or decreased during any of the successive time periods. The addition of 5% CO2 to the hyperoxic mixture greatly reduced or eliminated responses in most structures (Figure 1). The hypercapnic hyperoxia challenge elicited responses in dis- crete additional areas, in particular, the dorsal midbrain. Effect sizes in regions of signiﬁcant response ranged from small (0.1) to medium (0.3; Table 1).
The responses varied across time, as shown in Figure 2. Some structures, such as the caudate and hypothalamus, responded to hyperoxia during the initial 24–48 s, whereas other structures, such as the insula and cerebellum, responded throughout the challenge. Most notably, compared to 100% O2, hypercapnic hyperoxia resulted in fewer regions of immediate response, and eliminated all responses after the ﬁrst 48 s of the challenge.
The insula responded to hyperoxia alone bilaterally in posterior regions during the ﬁrst 24 s, followed by a reduction in response up to 48 s. Subsequently, the entire structure was
recruited, with a greater extent of the anterior right insula
involved. The addition of CO2 reduced the insula response to only the ﬁrst 24 s, and with smaller regions of response occurring more anteriorly than the initial hyperoxic changes.
where F is the F ratio and df degrees of freedom . The
maximum and minimum effect sizes for regions in each signiﬁcance map were presented, as opposed to whole-brain effect size maps. Each signiﬁcance map was presented as a colored overlay onto a background high-resolution anatomic image. In addition, a summary presentation combining all time points of signiﬁcant response was created for the two gas challenges, providing an overview of all responsive regions.
These data were previously used in part as control for examination of responses to chemoreceptor challenges in patients with congenital central hypoventilation syndrome (CCHS) [28-30]. In these earlier studies, hyperoxia responses in the normal participants were not examined separately, and a different analysis (population-level ‘‘random-effects’’ anal- ysis, single boxcar) was used to evaluate the normal responses to hypercapnia. These data were also used to study global BOLD signal responses in the patient group , and to
The 100% O2 challenge elicited hypothalamic and poste- rior thalamic changes within the ﬁrst 24 s, following which reduced responses appeared in thalamic regions for the remainder of the challenge. The hypothalamic responses to hyperoxia disappeared with addition of CO2, as did bilateral signal changes in the head of the caudate. The head of the caudate showed bilateral early responses to 100% O2, but only left-side reactions after 24 s. The hypercapnia/hyperoxia challenge elicited signal changes in the posterior and mid- thalamus similar to those found with hyperoxia, showing the greatest responses in the 24–48 s period.
Signal changes in the dorsal hippocampus to 100% O2 appeared late, after 48 s, and to a greater extent on the right side. The addition of 5% CO2 elicited immediate responses in the bilateral ventral hippocampi, rather than the dorsal portions; this pattern was sustained during the ﬁrst 48 s of the challenge.
Figure 1. Summary of Regions of Significant Response to Gas Challenges
Yellow (hyperoxia) and green (hypercapnic hyperoxia) overlays of regions of significant signal response in 14 children at any of five time successive periods during the challenges. Multiple brain regions responded to hyperoxia (100% O2), but the addition of 5% CO2 to the gas mixture greatly reduced most responses. Statistical threshold p 0.05, false discovery rate correction. Location guide key: CC, cerebellum; DMT, dorsal medial thalamus; Hypo, hypothalamus; LAI/RAI, left/right anterior insula; LAP/RAP, left/right posterior insula; LCN/RCN, left/right caudate nucleus; LG, lingual gyrus; LHipp/ RHipp, left/right hippocampus; LI/RI, left/right insula; PLT, posterior lateral thalamus; VLT, ventral lateral thalamus. Distances from the anterior commissure and orientation, based on the standard Montreal Neurological Institute space, are (A) 5 mm superior, (B) 5 mm left, (C) 27 mm right, and (D) 19 mm posterior. Distance increases from left-to-right for sagittal (side) views, posterior-to-anterior for coronal views, and inferior to superior for axial (transverse) views. The background image is a high-resolution scan from a single participant (normalized to Montreal Neurological Institute space). doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040173.g001
The cerebellum showed immediate and extensive responses to hyperoxia, with both cerebellar cortex and deep nuclei patterns developing during the ﬁrst 48 s. The addition of CO2 eliminated most cerebellar changes, with muted reactions appearing only during the 24–48 s period of the challenge, and only in the cerebellar cortex.
Table 1. Overview of Effect Sizes Calculated Using Pearson’s r for Regions of Significant Response
Hypercapnic Hyperoxia Effect
In each numeric range of the challenge responses, the smaller value represents the threshold as determined using false discovery rate correction for multiple comparisons (i.e., minimum significant effect), and the larger value represents the effect at the voxel of highest significance (i.e., maximum significant effect). doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040173.t001
Isolated regions of response to hyperoxia appeared in the medial lingual gyrus of the occipital lobe throughout the challenge, but disappeared with the addition of CO2. Addi- tional small, isolated regions in the posterior ventral–lateral parietal cortex emerged with both challenges within the ﬁrst 48 s.
We found that a number of brain areas responded to a hyperoxic challenge, especially neural regions that mediate autonomic and hormonal systems. However, addition of 5% CO2 to the hyperoxic mixture substantially reduced reactions of these neural structures. The perfusion and hormonal changes to 100% O2 could initiate a cascade of central and peripheral injuries through oxidative stress processes com- monly reported with high oxygen ventilation. Since the structures recruited in hyperoxia control output of hypo- thalamic sympathetic and hormonal regulatory areas, the reduced responses of those structures with the addition of CO2 may diminish injury to central and peripheral organs following hyperoxia alone, a possibility suggested by others . The brain regions activated in hyperoxia have long been known to project heavily to hypothalamic areas mediating
Figure 2. Time-Specific Regions of Response to Gas Challenges
Hyperoxia (top rows, yellow) and hypercapnic hyperoxia (bottom rows, green) overlays of regions of significant signal response in 14 children at five successive time periods during the challenges (time scale below images). Location guide and views (A–D) are the same as in Figure 1. As shown by images in the top rows, multiple brain regions responded to hyperoxia, but addition of 5% CO2 to the gas mixture altered the timing or greatly reduced most responses (bottom rows), and eliminated all responses after 48 s. Statistical threshold p 0.05, false discovery rate correction. doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.0040173.g002
autonomic and hormonal regulation. The insular cortex projects to hypothalamic and amygdala sites, and recording, stimulation, and stroke injury evidence demonstrates a lateralized and topographic organization of parasympathetic, sympathetic, and baroreﬂex regulation for that structure in animals and humans [16–18,35–39]. The substantial recruit- ment of the insula in hyperoxia, especially on the right side, likely reﬂects a role in mediating sympathetic components of
the challenge. In the absence of CO2, the insula remains recruited throughout the challenge period, consistent with a sustained increase in sympathetic outﬂow; abolition of this response with addition of CO2 undoubtedly modiﬁes inﬂu- ences on hypothalamic sites, decreasing sympathetic tone.
Cerebellar cortex and deep nuclei apparently serve a role in modifying blood pressure and in limiting extremes of blood pressure change [37,40,41], including recruitment of
motor actions to compensate for hypotension , and may serve a similar role for sympathetic action during hyperoxia. Cerebellar cortex and deep nuclei were extensively recruited during the ﬁrst 24 s of the hyperoxia challenge, correspond- ing to the initial period of vasoconstriction and the accompanying blood pressure increase. Reduced hypothala- mic sympathetic outﬂow via insular responses, combined with CO2 counteracting O2-induced vasoconstriction, would result in more modest blood pressure changes, and hence a reduced need for recruitment of the cerebellum to modulate the changes; indeed, cerebellar responses to CO2 addition were reduced or eliminated from those of hyperoxia alone.
The hippocampus has pronounced anatomic projections to the hypothalamus as well as to the insula and amygdala [35,43,44], reacts to electrical stimulation with blood pressure increases , and activates with blood pressure manipu- lation  or respiratory patterns that elicit blood pressure changes . The dorsal hippocampus was recruited later in the hyperoxia challenge. The addition of CO2 resulted in larger initial ventral hippocampal responses, especially from 24 to 48 s, with later changes abolished. The precise function of the hippocampal response to these challenges remains speculative, but may be related to blood pressure interactions with respiratory changes; the respiratory changes occur early in response to CO2, but over a longer period of time to 100% O2.
An area showing immediate recruitment in response only to the hypercapnic/hyperoxic mixture, but not to hyperoxia, was the dorsal midbrain, with more extensive responses during the 24–48 s challenge period. The responsive region included dorsal portions of the periaqueductal gray matter, which contains respiratory neurons with poorly known inﬂuences on respiratory patterning in the cat ; stim- ulation of the dorsal periaqueductal gray region also elicits effects on respiratory musculature [48,49]. It is unclear whether a portion of the reduction of hypothalamic and insular signals during hypercapnic hyperoxia results from processes induced by dorsal midline recruitment.
The ﬁndings suggest that the common medical practice of hyperoxic gas administration may beneﬁt from CO2 supple- mentation through reduction of central neural responses accompanying hyperoxia-induced sympathetic outﬂow and hormonal release. A portion of the often detrimental peripheral outcomes, e.g., alterations in myocardial contrac- tility, reduced myocardial relaxation, and certain hormonal effects such as increased glucagon levels, may result from alterations in autonomic site function in the brain.
Supplementation of hyperoxia with CO2 does reduce induction of hypocapnia and consequent reductions in CBF, and alleviates damage due to oxygen stress. The biochemical processes associated with tissue injury in oxygen stress have been well-outlined [50,51], as have interventions to prevent such injury . CO2 supplementation for neonatal resuscitation is indicated by suggestions that room air may be at least as effective as 100% O2 in infants subjected to asphyxia [53,54] and that biochemical correlates of oxygen stress are diminished . Room air resuscitation results in less injury to the heart and kidney ; injury to the heart is especially apparent after hyperoxic exposure . Similarly, hyperbaric O2 fared no better than pressurized air for improvement in gross motor function when administered to patients with cerebral palsy , and hyperoxia and hypo-
capnia add to the risk of brain injury after intrapartum asphyxia . Hyperoxic ventilation is often administered for treatment of stroke; however, the accompanying hypocapnia and resultant CBF reductions and diminished O2 delivery may be contraindicated, as for resuscitation. The perinatal ischemic rodent brain is better protected with addition of mild hypercapnia to the ventilatory supplement mix .
It should be noted that patients requiring resuscitation often show initially high CO2 levels following respiratory failure, and an argument could be made that under such circumstances the addition of CO2 to hyperoxic delivery is unnecessary. However, CO2 levels rapidly dissipate with forced ventilation, and hypocapnia would ensue after a short period, leading to the sequence of constricted vasculature described earlier.
It is important to note that children were used in the present study. The ﬁndings may not extend to adults, or to neonates, in whom resuscitation with hyperoxia is much more of a concern. We expect that the ﬁndings will generalize at least to adults, as a previous fMRI study of a hyperoxic hypercapnic challenge in a mixed adult/pediatric population shows comparable results in the dorsal pons and cerebellum ; the previous study was limited to midline areas.
It should be cautioned that determination of local activity within a regional brain area with fMRI depends on deoxygenation/oxygenation changes within those regions. Such measures are confounded by global changes in blood ﬂow and deoxyhemoglobin levels associated with the gas challenges. Although the gas challenges induce major changes in CBF, the detrending method used ensures that regional responses found in the fMRI data are unlikely to result from changes in CBF . CBF changes occur throughout the vasculature, and therefore are represented in the data as a change in the global signal, i.e., the average intensity signal across the whole brain. We developed a detrending method that removes any component of the data matching the global signal ; for any remaining signal to correspond to changes in CBF, those changes would have to be of a different timing and amplitude pattern than the majority of the CBF changes, which is unlikely given the interconnected nature of the cerebral vasculature. Minor timing differences in CBF response between regions will not affect the detrending as the fMRI volumes were collected at six-second intervals. We also segmented gray and white matter, as the vascular response differs slightly between these two tissue types [23,24]. Given the segmentation of gray matter and the application of conservative detrending, the ﬁndings should represent primarily regional responses.
One consequence of the detrending method used is that any regional responses corresponding to neural activity changes that follow a similar time course to the vascular changes are removed. Therefore, the results likely do not represent all of the neural activation–related signal changes that occurred with the challenges.
A ﬁnal consideration is the potential inﬂuence of the varying CO2 and O2 levels on the magnitude of the BOLD effect; these gases can alter the extent of neurally related hemodynamic changes [62,63]. However, although the BOLD effect is inﬂuenced by extreme changes in baseline CO2 (e.g., 10%) and O2 (e.g., 9%), the regional effect is robust across a range of hypercapnic, hypoxic, and hyperoxic conditions. Measurements in rats show that the regional hemodynamic
response is similar under 5% CO2 hypercapnia to normo- capnic conditions , with comparable ﬁndings in humans with 4% CO2 . Increases (up to 100% O2) and moderate decreases in oxygenation also do not lead to changes in regional BOLD responses . With the current study’s 5% CO2 and hyperoxic conditions, if changes in the BOLD effect did occur, they likely had little inﬂuence on the ﬁndings.
In summary, hyperoxic ventilation modiﬁed activity in several rostral brain structures that regulate autonomic and hormonal outﬂow, and these modiﬁcations may underlie a portion of the adverse autonomic and hormonal changes associated with treatment. Addition of CO2 to the hyperoxic gas mixture reduced the neural responses found during hyperoxia alone, and the response decline in neural modulatory areas may serve to mitigate the deleterious physiologic consequences of high oxygen.